I believe the man is sleeping on one, Titus "LeFiasco" Teague.
First Team All-Big East
…………Offense………............................….Defense
QB B.J. Daniels (USF)……………DE Greg Lloyd, Jr. (Connecticut)
RB Dion Lewis (Pittsburgh)………DT Chris Neild (West Virginia)
RB Noel Devine (West Virginia)…..DT Derek Wolfe (Cincinnati)
WR Jon Baldwin (Pittsburgh)…….DE Greg Romeus (Pittsburgh)
WR Mohamed Sanu (Rutgers)……LB Lawrence Wilson (Connecticut)
WR Armon Binns (Cincinnati)……..LB JK Schaeffer (Cincinnati)
TE Ben Guidugli (Cincinnati)………LB Scott Lutrus (Connecticut)
C Moe Petrus (Connecticut)……….LB JT Thomas (West Virginia)
OG Alex Hoffman (Cincinnati)………CB Kayvon Webster (USF)
OG Zach Hurd (Connecticut)……….CB Brandon Hogan (West Virginia)
OT Jason Pinkston (Pittsburgh)……..S Dom DeCicco (Pittsburgh)
OT Art Forst (Rutgers)……………….S Robert Sands (West Virginia)
KR Robbie Frey (Connecticut)………..K Tyler Bitancurt (West Virginia)
PR Jock Sanders (West Virginia)……..P Rob Long (Syracuse)
Second Team All-Big East
…………..Offense………..................……………….Defense
QB Tom Savage (Rutgers)………………DE Jonathan Freeny (Rutgers)
RB Jordan Todman (Connecticut)………DT Scott Vallone (Rutgers)
RB Delone Carter (Syracuse)……………DT Terrell McClain (USF)
WR Jock Sanders (West Virginia)………..DE Julian Miller (West Virginia)
WR Doug Beaumont (Louisville)………….LB Max Gruder (Pittsburgh)
WR DJ Woods (Cincinnati)……………….LB Derrell Smith (Syracuse)
TE Cameron Graham (Louisville)…………LB Pat Lazear (West Virginia)
C Sampson Genus (USF)………………….LB Greg Williams (Pittsburgh)
OG Chris Jacobson (Pittsburgh)………….CB David Rowe (Rutgers)
OG Josh Jenkins (West Virginia)…………..CB Dominique Battle (Cincinnati)
OT Don Barclay (West Virginia)…………….S Max Suter (Syracuse)
OT Lucas Nix (Pittsburgh)…………………S Mike Holmes (Syracuse)
KR Joe Lefeged (Rutgers)……………….K Jacob Rogers (Cincinnati)
PR Mohamed Sanu (Rutgers)…………….P Teddy Dellaganna (Rutgers)
Third Team All-Big East
……………….Offense……………....................……….Defense
QB Zach Collaros (Cincinnati)……………….DE Chandler Jones (Syracuse)
RB Victor Anderson (Louisville)………………DT Scooter Berry (West Virginia)
RB Isaiah Pead (Cincinnati)…………………..DT John Hughes (Cincinnati)
WR Brad Starks (West Virginia)………………DE Alex Silvestro (Rutgers)
WR Vidal Hazelton (Cincinnati)……………….LB Manny Abreu (Rutgers)
WR Kashif Moore (Connecticut)………………LB Dan Mason (Pittsburgh)
TE Ryan Griffin (Connecticut)…………………LB Doug Hogue (Syracuse)
C Ryan Bartholomew (Syracuse)……………..LB Antwon Canady (Louisville)
OG Jason Kelce (Cincinnati)…………………..CB Keith Tandy (West Virginia)
OG Eric Jobe (West Virginia)………………….CB Jarred Holley (Pittsburgh)
OT Byron Stingily (Louisville)…………………..S Joe Lefeged (Rutgers)
OT Jeff Adams (Louisville)……………………..S Drew Frey (Cincinnati)
KR Tavon Austin (West Virginia)…………….K Dan Hutchins (Pittsburgh)
PR Aaron Smith (Pittsburgh)…………………P Dan Hutchins (Pittsburgh)
Fourth Team All-Big East
………………….Offense…………………....................……Defense
QB Zach Frazer (Connecticut)……………….DE Jabaal Sheard (Pittsburgh)
RB Joe Martinek (Rutgers)……………………..DT Kendall Reyes (Connecticut)
RB Moise Plancher (USF)……………………….DT Myles Caragein (Pittsburgh)
WR Dontavia Bogan (USF)……………………..DE Mikhail Marinovich (Syracuse)
WR Marcus Sales (Syracuse)………………….LB Antonio Lowery (Rutgers)
WR Josh Chichester (Louisville)………………..LB Brandon Heath (Louisville)
TE DC Jefferson (Rutgers)………………………LB Walter Stewart (Cincinnati)
C Joe Madsen (West Virginia)………………….LB Sam Barrington (USF)
OG Mark Wetterer (Louisville)…………………CB Quenton Washington (USF)
OG Sam Griffin (Cincinnati)……………………CB Johnny Patrick (Louisville)
OT Zach Hermann (USF)……………………….S Sidney Glover (West Virginia)
OT Jacob Sims (USF)……………………………S Jerome Junior (Connecticut)
KR Dontavia Bogan (USF)……………………….K Ryan Lichtenstein (Syracuse)
PR Faron Hornes (USF)………………………….P Corey Smith (West Virginia)
Selections by team
West Virginia: 20
Cincinnati: 16
Pittsburgh/Rutgers: 15
Connecticut/USF: 12
Syracuse: 11
Louisville: 10
Breakdowns of each squad
First Team: West Virginia 7, Connecticut 6, Cincinnati/Pittsburgh 5, Rutgers/USF 2, Syracuse 1
Second Team: Rutgers 7, West Virginia 5, Pittsburgh/Syracuse 4, Cincinnati 3, Louisville/USF 2, Connecticut 1
Third Team: Cincinnati 6, West Virginia 5, Louisville/Pittsburgh/Rutgers 4*, Syracuse 3, Connecticut 2
Fourth Team: USF 8, Syracuse 6, Louisville 4, Connecticut/West Virginia 3, Rutgers/Pittsburgh 2, Cincinnati 1
I guess it's just a tough break for us that all wins, losses and other statistics for the 2010 college football season are going to be based solely on the predictions of preseason publications this year. It's an odd move, but once these conference presidents get their heads wrapped around an idea...