Conflicted Feelings in the Ol' Rivalry Belly
I want to begin by taking just a sentence or two to acknowledge and thank Mike and the cast of regulars that pepper this site with one liners, fan posts, and even full game breakdowns that all effectively act as commentary gold. Because of the Card Chronicle, this has been the most entertaining and fully developed season of Cards and college basketball that I have ever experienced.
With that being said, I can't believe that my first true impulse to add to this tangled web of information and emotional purging comes to me by the hands, or rather the foot of a Marquette Golden Eagle.
I've never liked Dominic James for all the obvious reasons. First, he established himself as the floor leader of one of our more bitter rivals in Marquette. Second, he did it as a freshman, solidifying his place alongside Laettner, Prickett, and Diener as a guy who would seemingly take a decade to graduate from college. Third, he was a pretty good ball player on both ends of the floor; lightning quick, good handles, good defense, decent shot. And finally, because he always seemed to have better than "pretty good" games against UofL.
So when I heard at halftime of the UConn / Marquette game that James was out indefinitely with a foot injury, and later, that indefinitely meant the end of his college career due to a break of the fifth metatarsal in his left foot, I was surprised by my immediate thoughts. As a fan, I instantly began to analyze what the injury meant in terms of the rivalry rejuvenation on Sunday, and once I came to the conclusion that Marquette might now have its hands more full than it did before the UConn loss, I felt a bit cheated. I have been looking forward to this particular matchup all year; I thought in October that Pitt was a good matchup for us, UConn a bad one, but even after watching Marquette's team, the core of which is comprised of 3 senior guards, I really had no idea how UofL and the Golden Eagles would handle each other. While I still fear what Marquette could do at the White Out, I honestly don't fear it as much. And if I feel cheated, I can only imagine how Dominic James feels.
Which brings me to the aforementioned feelings of confliction that now reside deep inside my gut. Yes, I despise Dominic James for all the reasons outlined above, but venturing deeper into my soul, I come to find why I like him even more. The reasons to like James are far more obvious than the reasons not to. First, he's a true leader. James leads on the court with his play, not his mouth. His threes are assassins, but of the silent variety. He doesn't argue every call. He tries as hard as he can to beat you; when he does he's content, when he doesn't he's gracious. Second, he makes his teammates better. McNeal and Matthews were not national names like James was coming out of high school. But, over the course of four years, James' decision to spread the ball instead of hog it is what ultimately put Marquette in the position to do great things this year, until the injury. Finally, he's a senior. Men like Dominic James and Terrence Williams are slowly becoming a dying breed. Sure, both have tustled with the idea of leaving early for the NBA, but both listened to reliable sources and made good decisions, even when it meant acknowledging weaknesses in their games. Once those decisions were made, they both fully committed to their teams and communities.
Seniors like these should be cherished by the teams' fans, but also by the game's fans. College basketball needs sturdy players like James to solidify its place as the best sport in America. It is a shame to see an injury like this interrupt the last chapter of a great collegiate athlete's career, especially when this instance can now be the example that the agents and friends at home need in attempting to convince the next T Will or DJ to leave early.
"Go Cards" as always, but I hope that on Sunday Dominic James is on the floor when his team is warming up an hour or so before the game. If he is, I might take the time to walk down and tell him all the reasons that Cards fans hated seeing him check into games, but why they hate seeing him on the sidelines even more.
24 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Zakem, that was a very thoughtful and mature post
showing a rare sense of appreciation for the opposing player and the history of this rivalry.
Yes, we hate them BECAUSE of both the glory -and heartache-we have felt in our tilts with them.
A great rival deserves the great respect on any # of levels. A true sportsman—a sportsman in the old sense of the word—would want their rival at their best—for the quality of the match and so that the glory will be untainted in victory.
And now that the thoughtfulness is over: Let’s beat the crap out of those cheeseheads now that we have them exactly where we want them!!
you must be inadvertently hitting the ...
“S” next to the italic sign before you post your comments…..the “S” with the line through it is the only way you’d get that…………………………
Wow, a "Diener" mention
…now what a pain in the ass he was! P E S T . Said as a compliment of, course.
By the way, he was recently spotted in my niece Sarah’s Soph Art History 101 course…needing just a couple more credits to graduate.
Good stuff, Zakem.
Frank, what the hell are you doing out there? Get those “strike outs” under control. Get….
Existential.
Totally agree on all levels
I always felt the same way about James as i did about Wade when he was at Marquette. i always like watchign both of them play with such energy, passion, control and skill, but i absolutly hated when they played like that against UL.
I always felt when you played your rivals, you wanted them to be as strong as possible, and while we all hope certain teams loose and collapse every game (for many its UK), there is no questioning the rivalries we have with many teams are much better when both teams are ranked, playing well, and healthy.
Its so funny
B/c I actually texted Mike about this situation last night. I may have never liked James but I was literally sick to my stomach upset for the kid. He has played his ass off and finally their team may have made some noise for once in the torunament and he’s out for good and it severely hurts in chance he has off getting drafted.
On a more selfish note, the injuries to James and Dyson upset me b/c all I want is for the Big East to completely dominate the Tournament and stop all the BS talk about the ACC and put the SEC in their places. And with these 2 key injuries I worry about UConn and Marquette’s chances in the tournament and then talks about how the Big East was overrated, blah blah blah. Hopefully it all works out for the best
Great essay on sportsmanship
When I saw him go down I was a little disheartened. Not so much b/c I really wanted him on the floor against us, I’ll take whatever advantage I can get, but because any chance Marquette had of beating UConn crumbled with James’ foot.
James is a great competitor and as far as I can tell a swell guy, I certainly don’t have the disdain for him that I had for Diener, whose name still makes my eye twitch. So I wish him the best, but I’m perfectly happy to face a Golden Eagle team whose deadly guard trifecta has been reduced to a deadly guard tandem.
But Marquette gave UConn all they could handle last night, so I hope no one thinks this injury means they can’t beat us. Because if we don’t play our asses off they probably will.
e
Nice
I never like to see somebody get hurt. I always want to beat the other team, but want to do so with all the key players in place. Otherwise, it seems to deserve an asterisk. Was hoping at least that UConn would get beat by Marquette to set up an even bigger game on Sunday (even without James).
Yeah, I also seem to remember Diener playing for about seven years. Maybe you can play as grad student at Marquette. Just kidding.
I’ll be getting up early for the 9AM start here on the west coast.
GO CARDS!
Sorry for James
For a senior to break his foot this late in his career is dishearteningly sad. An unfortunate end to a somewhat bizarre career. We all remember how well James played as a freshman, and how energized he has always been during his four years at Marquette. No one could ever doubt the kid’s heart. But what happened to his shot?
Over the years, it seems, it just disappeared. It was as if once the ball stopped going in, he changed his form — almost from one attempt to the next. I don’t know what happened, but I wonder if it’s possible that this break in his foot came over time. If he’s been experiencing pain and if that hasn’t contributed to the weirdness of his shot. Every good shooter knows that the shot begins at the very bottom — it starts in the feet then processes through the body until it comes out the fingertips. If there’s a problem at the start, there will be a problem at the end. It might explain what happened this year, though it surely doesn’t answer his decreased scoring throughout his sophomore and junior years.
Whatever the cause, you can’t help but feel sorry for a four-year kid who doesn’t get the chance to play in the tournament in his final year.
theoldman
if tom crean were still there, i'd only have one thing to say:
“HE’S FAKING!”
But now that Buzz “IHOP” Williams is the coach, i agree with the post in its entirety.
Marquette Fan
I logged on to this site expecting to see a bunch of posts from rabid Louisville fans licking their chops knowing that they’ll be facing a team lacking one critical piece in Dominic James. I have to thank you for showing such gamesmanship in what has become such a fierce rivalry. While my expectations for this season were just cut in third with James’ injury, at least I’ll know that Louisville fans respect the game and the rivalry and would want to see our teams play at full strength. Good luck on Sunday… I think it’ll be a great game!
Interesting Dynamic
Think about it: as UofL fans, you don’t like Dominic James against the Cards, but you root for Marquette in every non-conference game they play. Did anyone else throw their remote down in anger when one of the Lopez brothers hit that miracle shot in the tournament last year?
MU Fan
I would agree that I root for all BE teams when they are playing non BE teams. All of them. And I am disappointed when they lose any of those games. I strongly root for the BE, particularly because I am tired of hearing about the ACC. In that, I think we can all agree. Most of us probably feel that way. Hearing that DJ was out of the season made me feel sick. It not only is bad for MU but the BE. Nevertheless, I am confident that MU will find a way to win. Acker has and will fill in ok, but there is only one DJ.
by CitizenPortlander on Feb 26, 2009 6:31 PM EST up reply actions
Thanks
I landed here from a link on a Marquette blog and would like to thank you for
those kind words. It was extremely well written. I am not sure I would have been
so gracious if the shoe were on the other foot, so to speak. It goes to show, when you
take a step back and take in the big picture, most people are empathetic and down to earth.
Thanks again for that great piece and may we see just a ‘damn great basketball’ on Sunday.
Class Act
That was a nice piece on DJ. As a die hard alum I have not been able to come to grips with such a loss for this kid. It is hard to see any senior finish his career like that. It is nice to know that there are still fans, although bitter rivals, who display class and integrity in a time when those characteristics are rarely seen. Well done.
Nice post
Let me add that Dominic is definitely one of those opposing players I respect the most from the past few years. First, he grabbed my attention quickly. I remember being extra relieved when Deiner retired from college ball after 15 seasons, and thinking, "Thank goodness that Marquette will be without that type of point guard leadership." Dominic introduced himself to the Cardinals with a 16-point, 11 rebound, 6 assist performance on Taquan Dean’s senior day. The Cards won in overtime (wow, a close game with Marquette – who knew?), but I left very concerned that Marquette had somehow upgraded at the PG spot. And he’d be around for 3 more years.
As you wrote, the kid has just the type of attitude you want for all of the kids on your own team. He reminds of Dean a lot in that respect, and he is just a flat out amazing athlete and leader.
I also agree that Marquette has developed into one of those heated rivalries where I want to smoke them each match up, but I always find myself cheering for them in the conference games. Perhaps it’s their solid record against UK in the tournament. But they basically have a pretty likeable team (once you get past the old coach).
I can’t imagine how terrible it must be to make it this far into your senior year, have it be such a special year, and then watch it fall apart so quickly. I suppose it is good news that he can recover fully and relatively quickly from his injury, but in some sense, perhaps that makes it harder on him to sit out these last few weeks, wishing instead that he could have sustained his injury when TWill did – before the season – and kept his senior year on course. My sympathy certainly goes out to DJ. But I still hope we show no mercy to the Golden Eagles.
GoldenEaglesFan
I appreciated your post. Please check out my Blog.
I will be attending the game on Sunday and DJ is a friend of mine so I will be sitting behind their bench. If DJ does attend the game, I can introduce you to him.
by GoldenEaglesFan on Feb 26, 2009 7:26 PM EST reply actions
Classy post Zakem
Marquette fan here. I had the good fortune of being in row 1 last night near the MU bench. At least I thought it was good fortune until I saw DJ finally come out, on crutches, for the second half. It was absolutely gut wrenching. He’s had ups and downs, but his leadership has been beyond question, and this year, he’d carved out the perfect role as a lock-down defender and ball distributor. Things were going so well, and now, there he is, 20 feet away with that thousand-yard stare, still in shock, wondering what will happen to the team he loves and, undoubtedly, his professional prospects.
I hope we find a way to beat UL Sunday, but knowing fans like you guys understand the bigger picture helps keep things in perspective. Good luck the rest of the way.
I think it might help
Marquette from a psychological standpoint. The other players will be incredibly fired up and focused on getting a big win for their leader. The Cards better come with their ‘A’ game or Marquette will win. I’m not in the camp of those that think this helps Louisville. I think, on balance, it makes Marquette tougher to beat now, since this is the next game after James’ injury.
I agree, CardsFanTX
If we don’t break them by the 10 min mark in the 2nd half, MU will have a psychological momentum that could prove the difference come crunch time.
by UL is my hot hot sex on Feb 27, 2009 10:48 AM EST up reply actions
Nice post
Glad I wasn’t the only one in the ‘ville who was saddened by it. Terrible for James especially, and you gotta feel for him. Bad too for the game Sunday, Marquette’s chances, and the Big East as a whole.

by 








