On the legacy of Hunter Cantwell
Regardless of whether his collegiate swan song is comprised of him throwing four touchdowns in a victory or four interceptions in a loss, Hunter Cantwell's Louisville legacy has already been cemented.
The former walk-on from Paducah will forever be remembered as a kid with a cannon for an arm who made some key starts and throws in U of L's most successful football season to date, but who ultimately disappointed in is first and only season as the Cardinals' starting quarterback.
It's an accurate synopsis, but it doesn't tell nearly the whole story.
The season Cantwell had waited his entire life for took its first hit when Mario Urrutia declared for early entry into the NFL Draft last Dec. 14. The aptly sized quarterback and the aptly sized wide receiver had a special connection from the first time they stepped on the field together, and Urrutia was on the receiving end of nearly half of the ten touchdown passes Cantwell had to his credit heading into this season. He then began to form a similar bond with Scott Long which was cut off when the No. 1 receiver in waiting broke a bone in his foot before the season, resumed when he returned and went off for 134 yards and a pair of scores, and terminated when he tore his ACL and was shelved for the season.
On the whole, the quarterback Mel Kiper had pegged as the top in his class this time a year ago has struggled every bit as much as the team he's commanded in 2008. He's tossed an identical 16 touchdowns and interceptions while guiding the Cards to an up-and-down 5-6 season heading into tomorrow night's regular season finale at Rutgers.
When Hunter Cantwell's final snap as a Louisville Cardinal has come and gone, it'll be far too easy to remember the long release, the batted passes, the staring down of one receiver and the disappointing season. What's more difficult but probably more suitable is to remember Cantwell as the player who chose to stay at Louisville when it probably wasn't the best move for him personally.
He had the opportunity to be a three-year starter at a mid-level D-1 program after giving a gutsy performance in the '06 Gator Bowl, and then the opportunity to be a two-year starter at a major D-1 program after his rocket arm was on full display in a highly publicized demolition of Miami. In both instances Cantwell chose to stay, not because he thought he had the chance to unseat Brian Brohm or because he thought Brohm would bolt early for the NFL, but because he wanted to remain loyal to the U of L football program.
"I walked on at Louisville and it was the only Division I-A school that gave me a chance," Cantwell said before this season. "I just felt a lot of loyalty to the school and my coaches. As tough as it was, and even when people were always telling me, 'transfer, transfer, transfer,' I couldn't imagine leaving Louisville."
And that's what should define Hunter Cantwell's legacy as a Louisville Cardinal.
Comments
Great post Mike..
Its easy for those great early moments of his career to be forced in the shadow of what has transpired this season. I always did think that Hunter was an outstanding QB.
Its hard to be successful at that position if you dont have any go-to receivers. Kind of like trying to have a great basketball team without a good point guard.
by twistedwedge on
Dec 3, 2008 7:28 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I have one comment
After watching those highlights from the Miami game, I have one thought.
I HATE Steve Kragthorpe!
by Whacker77 on
Dec 3, 2008 11:37 AM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
bingo
i say find out where he lives, and run him out of town
by davidson07 on
Dec 3, 2008 6:55 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
I’ve always felt bad for Hunter. The fact is he wasn’t ever really a very good QB, but everyone completely ignored that because he took a hit like a man and he had a rocket arm. He was a victim of a kind of hype that you see all the time in basketball, but only really effects QBs in football. In basketball, a kid’s athleticism or size always seems overshadow what he’s actually done on the court (Kwame Brown, Darko, etc.), but in football you almost never see scouts completely ignore a player’s actual skills. You would never see a scout look at a RB and say, “well, he’s really fast, but he can’t block, he can’t catch, and he can’t run up the middle. Let’s take him in the first round”. Or imagine a LB who is sure tackler, but can’t shed blocks, can’t cover the pass, and has terrible lateral movement being considered a first rounder. It just wouldn’t happen. But with QBs, a strong arm seems to overshadow everything. Nobody cared that Ryan Leaf sucked. He had a strong arm. Jeff George? Akili Smith? Kyle Boller? The list goes on and on and on. Matt Stafford is probably going to be a first round draft pick, based entirely on his “prototypical size and strength”. Hunter never really had the skills to be a big time player at this level, let alone in the NFL. He stares down receivers. His height is worthless because of his slow release. His arm strength appears to come at the expense of any kind of touch at all. These were the reasons no one recruited him out of high school. They were the reasons Petrino never played him unless he had to, and even then limited what he was willing to do on offense with Hunter at the helm. These aren’t new developments, and I’m just constantly amazed that for four years no one from scouts and coaches to fans and analysts ever bothered to mention any of it.
by _TheGainesShow_ on
Dec 3, 2008 12:22 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
ouch.....
the truth hurts sometime but you wrote a very good blog bringing up some good points. U of L fans are generally very KIND people and God forbid, we EVER hurt anyone’s feelings but looking objectively at Hunter’s performance overall would indicate that perhaps you are right and that he never was up to the job while in college – who knows what a GOOD QB Coach could do with him in the pros. I would rather think that Mike is correct that losing Urritia and Long hurt Cantwell’s numbers last year and this year but if the skills are there, a really good QB adjusts. He couldn’t seem to. Great kid and I thank him for being loyal to U of L and wish him great success in the future. I hope he makes it to the pros and shows improvement under a GOOD coaching staff who can capitalize on his strengths and correct his weaknesses. Go CARDS !
by Linda on
Dec 3, 2008 12:58 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Reality sux
Very good points. He’s a great kid, there’s no doubt. But there are reasons why he didn’t get any D-1 offers coming out of high school. In order to be productive at the next level he’s going to have to change his throwing motion completely. That release just takes too long. In the NFL I fear he’ll suffer a similar fate as Andre Woodson. He’ll get drafted in the mid rounds and then cut at the end of training camp. He might make a practice squad.
by JMC1 on
Dec 3, 2008 2:29 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Cantwells delivery wasnt as long back in the day.. Look at the clips he never brings the ball to his waist. The harry over the middle isnt that clear but his release looks fast and you cant see his motion going to his waist at all.. Whats up?
by mapaul04 on
Dec 3, 2008 2:36 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Love that Video
That game and the Orange Bowl victory stayed on my DVR for over a year until I changed boxes.
Hunter is and always will be a Cardinal. We might have expected more from him than he was able to give, but he was a victim of a perfect storm of shit since Petrino’s departure.
by Peter McSheisty on
Dec 3, 2008 3:42 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
I'm glad I watched that video
I had forgotten what it looks like to have guys riding wide open downfield due to superior playcalling and design…
/stifles a sob
by quiet cardinal on
Dec 3, 2008 3:56 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Thanks for this post
I really hate hearing any criticism of college players that seem to be making a good effort. They’re not getting paid, and the coaches choose whether or not to keep them on the team and play them. If Kragthorpe asked me to fill in for QB in the next game, I’d be far worse than any player in UofL history, but you better believe I’d be out there. The coaches get paid millions to win, feel free to criticize any of their decisions. The players are out there because they’ve been given a chance to play. Hunter is a great guy, and a faithful Cardinal. I only have respect for him.
by Dais on
Dec 3, 2008 4:44 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs
Excellent post
Yes, though most college football players are on scholarship and get a debt-free college education (though Hunter originally walked on), I still think all of the time and hard work they’ve put into a program should be recognized. Hunter could have transferred to another high-profile school, especially when his stock was so high his freshman and sophomore years under Petrino, but he decided to remain loyal to the Ville. You have to appreciate that. His decision to spend four years at UofL before starting is comparable to Brohm’s decision to delay his entry to the NFL draft by one year.
by centrecard on
Dec 3, 2008 6:02 PM EST
up
reply
actions
0 recs
Miami video
…that video represents how far UL had come and encapsulates why the last 2 seasons leaves such a sour taste in our mouths. Every major program has off years but to have 2 straight freefall-off-the-radar seaons after finally—albeit falsely it seems—breaking that very visceral “Big Program” status…it’s a punch in the stomach. It makes you feel embarassed for ever boasting that our football team had “made it”. Schnelly’s quote about the collision course for a national championship? …turns out it was a collision course towards wildly premature self-gratulation.
Getting back to that Miami vid, the personality that they carried into that game is what UL has missed the most the past 2 yrs: daring teams to stomp the bird, then punching ‘em in the mouth (literally by Urrutia) on both sides of the field. Mario’s scream after that long TD pass was the apex of being a UL FB fan. You sensed the release of frustration after years of being considered a 2nd rate program…and it truly felt, in that moment, like it wasn’t just a sign of who UL could be…it was the turning point of what UL had become… but now we know it was all just as fleeting as success has always been for this program.
Say what you will about his untimely penalties this season, Eric Wood was the only UL player that showed consistent intensity and a desire to win throughout the entire season. Cantwell is a nice guy. Eric Wood is a football player. Louisville needs more football players.
Kragthorpe, Brohm—you’re on notice. Let’s turn this thing around.
by UL is my hot hot sex on
Dec 3, 2008 11:44 PM EST
reply
actions
0 recs










